For shoppers searching gotham steel air fryer reviews, this product is best understood as an oven accessory rather than a standalone appliance: a raised mesh basket sits over a solid tray to support air circulation and catch drips.
Its appeal is the ability to crisp, bake, roast, and reheat in a regular or convection oven, provided the round set fits your available rack space.
Gotham Steel Tray Review Summary
The quick verdict

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A two-piece oven crisper tray for cooks who want air-fried textures without adding a countertop appliance.
- Two-piece construction: a raised mesh basket sits above a solid drip tray.
- Round copper-colored set measuring about 13.12 inches across.
- Designed for regular ovens, convection ovens, and oven air-fry settings.
- The aluminum core has a Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.
Pros
- The raised basket creates space for hot air to circulate around food.
- The lower tray helps contain drips and loose crumbs instead of letting them fall directly onto the oven.
Consider before buying
- This is an oven accessory, so it depends on having a suitable oven or convection setting; it does not provide a separate heating appliance.
- The roughly 13-inch round shape may use rack space differently from rectangular cookware, so measure the oven’s usable area and nearby clearance.
Read the full review summary
The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray pairs a mesh basket with a solid copper-colored pan. The raised cooking surface is designed to let hot air move around food, while the lower pan catches grease and crumbs.
That combination makes it a practical option for oven-based fries, wings, vegetables, and other foods that benefit from airflow beneath them.
This format suits cooks who already use an oven or convection setting and want a dedicated basket-and-drip-pan setup without adding a separate fryer.
Its roughly 13-inch round footprint is described as suitable for most standard oven racks and small convection ovens, but checking the usable dimensions of your own oven is sensible before buying.
The buying factors
Gotham Steel Tray Scorecard
Editorial scores reflect listed features and buyer fit; they are not laboratory measurements or customer ratings.
Airflow-focused design
The elevated mesh basket is designed to leave space beneath food for hot-air circulation.
Cooking versatility
The tray is intended for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating in an oven.
Mess management
A solid pan under the basket catches grease and crumbs during cooking.
Cleanup convenience
The coated basket and pan are described as dishwasher safe and easy release.
Oven fit flexibility
Its round form is intended for many standard racks and small convection ovens, though dimensions still need checking.
Material and coating
The aluminum core and titanium-ceramic nonstick finish offer a lightweight tray format with a nonstick surface.
Key Features and Specifications of Gotham Steel Tray
- Two-piece construction: a raised mesh basket sits above a solid drip tray.
- Round copper-colored set measuring about 13.12 inches across.
- Designed for regular ovens, convection ovens, and oven air-fry settings.
- The aluminum core has a Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.
- Basket and tray are described as dishwasher safe, with easy-release cooking surfaces.
- The product description identifies the coating as free of PTHE, PFOA, and PFOS.
- The solid pan catches grease and crumbs below the mesh basket.
Pros and Cons of Gotham Steel Tray
Pros
- The raised basket creates space for hot air to circulate around food.
- The lower tray helps contain drips and loose crumbs instead of letting them fall directly onto the oven.
- One set is intended for air frying, baking, roasting, and reheating.
- The coating and dishwasher-safe construction are geared toward easier food release and cleanup.
Consider before buying
- This is an oven accessory, so it depends on having a suitable oven or convection setting; it does not provide a separate heating appliance.
- The roughly 13-inch round shape may use rack space differently from rectangular cookware, so measure the oven’s usable area and nearby clearance.
- A coated basket and pan require care appropriate to their nonstick surface; check the included care guidance before choosing utensils or cleaning methods.
Who Should Buy Gotham Steel Tray?
Good fit
Consider the Gotham Steel Crisper Tray if you already cook with an oven or convection mode and want a mesh surface for foods that can benefit from airflow underneath.
The paired drip pan is useful when you want one piece to support the food and another to catch grease and crumbs.
It may also appeal if you prefer a compact accessory to a separate countertop fryer.
Before ordering, compare the set’s approximately 13.12-inch diameter with your rack’s usable width and consider how much room you need to handle the pan with an oven mitt.
Who should skip it
Skip this format if you need an independent countertop appliance with its own heating controls, or if your oven cannot accommodate the round tray with room to handle it comfortably.
If your main goal is outdoor grilling or charcoal management, choose equipment designed for that cooking setup rather than an oven crisper tray.
What the Gotham Steel Tray Design Means in Practice
Airflow comes from the raised basket
The mesh basket holds food above the solid pan, leaving open space below and around it.
That arrangement is intended to help hot air reach more of the food’s surface than a flat pan alone; actual results will depend on the food, how it is arranged, and the oven setting.
The drip tray has a second job
The lower pan catches grease and crumbs, which can make the setup easier to manage than a basket used without a catch surface.
It also means there are two pieces to wash, although the product description says both are dishwasher safe.
Check the shape against your oven
A round tray can sit on many standard oven racks, but nominal diameter does not guarantee a comfortable fit in every oven.
Measure the rack’s usable space and account for the room needed to place and remove the tray, especially in a compact convection oven.
Coating convenience has care considerations
The titanium-ceramic finish is intended to support food release and easier cleanup.
As with any coated cookware, buyers should follow the care instructions supplied with the set and use compatible utensils and cleaning methods to preserve the cooking surface.
Alternatives to Gotham Steel Tray
Grill Baskets alternative

700+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsCave Tools Vegetable Grill Basket
Choose the Gotham Steel set for oven-based crisping with a dedicated drip tray. Consider the Cave Tools basket if your priority is cooking small foods over an outdoor grill and you want its stainless-steel basket and transport handle.
- The Cave Tools basket is a rectangular stainless-steel grill pan for small foods such as vegetables, shrimp, fish, meat, and fruit; it has a curved handle and is dishwasher safe.
- The Gotham Steel set is designed for oven and convection cooking, with a round mesh basket over a solid drip pan.
Grill Baskets alternative

1,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsKona Extra Large Grill Basket
Pick the Gotham Steel set when you want an oven basket paired with a crumb and grease-catching pan. The Kona is a more relevant fit for large servings of vegetables on an outdoor grill.
- The Kona basket is a 14-by-13-by-4-inch nonstick basket intended for outdoor grilling, with extra-large capacity for vegetables and a high-temperature construction.
- The Gotham Steel tray is a roughly 13-inch round oven accessory for air-fry, bake, roast, and reheat use.
Is Gotham Steel Tray Worth It?
The Gotham Steel Crisper Tray is worth considering if your goal is to add a raised, airflow-oriented cooking surface to an oven you already own.
Its two-piece arrangement, nonstick coating, and drip-catching pan make it a useful format for crisping and roasting without bringing in another appliance.
Its value depends on oven fit and your willingness to use a coated accessory with routine care. Measure your rack first; if the tray fits and you want oven-based crisping with easier cleanup, it is a sensible candidate.
Your review at a glance

13,000+ ratings
Read Amazon ReviewsGotham Steel Crisper Tray
A two-piece oven crisper tray for cooks who want air-fried textures without adding a countertop appliance.
- Two-piece construction: a raised mesh basket sits above a solid drip tray.
- Round copper-colored set measuring about 13.12 inches across.
- Designed for regular ovens, convection ovens, and oven air-fry settings.
- The aluminum core has a Gotham Steel titanium and ceramic nonstick coating.